Unfinished moonshine was a component in making Moonshine in the 2010 Hallowe'en event. It was made by using the Big bottle of blood on a Strained moonshine vial. First, the Big bottle of fear was added, and then the Pile of ground bones.
- If you left the Grim reaper's house with this item, the message "The Halloween items vanish. You feel a little strange." would show in the chatbox. This message also showed up if only one item was held when leaving.