Complete the puzzle by matching the labels with the boxes.
You can use the table below to guide you. Use the process of elimination to get it right. After trying a combination, mark it and proceed to the next. One by one, the wrong combination will be eliminated until Gus informs you that all boxes are labelled correctly. If a wrong combination is used, Gus can reset the puzzle.
Or, you can extract a creature from the box labeled "Newts and Toads" and put a label on it according to the creature you pulled out. Then, put the label "Newts and Toads" on the box labelled the creature you did not pull out. (For example, if you pulled out a toad, you would label the newt box "Newts and Toads", and vice versa.) Then put the remaining label on the remaining box. The first two rows are actually the only two possible outcomes.
The witches around Gielinor give additional rewards to members who have obtained the enchanted broomstick. Note that you can use temporary boosts, such as a magic potion, to reach the requirements, although the God Emissary banner boost does not work here.
For Kardia, do not attempt to go into her house directly as she will hit you for damage with a spell. Instead, pick up the Witch's cat from a platform to the northwest and use it on her door. It would then be possible to enter her house; use the broomstick with Kardia to get it enchanted.