EVIL DAVE v. The People

Overview	Evil Dave is accused of evilness.
Release date	1 September 2010
Length	3-10 minutes
Parties involved	Evil Dave Oziach Gypsy Aris Doris, Evil Dave's mum
Items used	Court summons
Experience	9,000 in any combat skill
Reward	1 Mystery box and 5 Spicy stew (Court Cases)

Images

To successfully prosecute Evil Dave, follow these steps before entering the courtroom:

Read through the three case reports. There are no fingerprints.
Interview Oziach, located in Edgeville. Go through all the chat options. Note: Oziach's chat options will not be available if you're holding an Anti-dragon shield. Drop or bank the shield and talk to him again to continue the case.
Interview Doris (Dave's mum), located in Edgeville. Go through all the chat options.
Interview Evil Dave, located in the courthouse. Go through all the chat options.

Then go into the courtroom below. Follow these steps:

Present the Hellrats as evidence. Say "Dave summoned them to do his evil bidding."
Call Oziach to the stand. Ask him about "Evil acts."
Call Doris (Dave's mum) to the stand. Ask her about "Dave's childhood."
Call Evil Dave to the stand. Ask him about "Hellrats."
Direct the closing statement at the ranger.

To successfully defend Evil Dave, follow these steps before entering the courtroom:

Read through the three case reports. There are no fingerprints.
Interview Oziach, located in Edgeville. Go through all the chat options.
Interview Doris (Dave's mum), located in Edgeville. Go through all the chat options.
Interview Gypsy Aris, located in Varrock. Go through all the chat options.
Interview Evil Dave, located in the courthouse. Go through all the chat options.
Interview Arresting Officer, located in the courthouse. Go through all the chat options.

Then go into the courtroom below and follow these steps:

Present hellrats as evidence. Say "They're just an infestation."
Present the evil stew as evidence. Say "The stew was created to help stop the Culinaromancer."
Present the fluffy pants as evidence. Say "A man who wears fluffy pants can't take over the world."
Call Oziach to the stand. Ask him about his "Opinion of Dave."
Call Doris (Dave's Mum) to the stand. Ask her about the "Fluffy pants."
Call Gypsy Aris to the stand. Ask her about the "Culinaromancer."
Direct the closing statement at the shady gentleman or the shady individual.

“	No! I want to appeal! I AM TERRIFYINGLY EVIL!	”
	— Evil Dave's shock when the court finds him not evil

If you call Evil Dave to the stand and ask him about every topic, the judge will rule him to be a liability to his case and order all his statements stricken from the record. This will render both his positive and negative responses neutral.
If you have an anti-dragon shield in your inventory or have it equipped, then you won't be able to talk to Oziach about Dave.
When presenting Evil Stew as evidence, the option "It's tasty, tasty, very very tasty" is a reference to a song used to advertise bran flakes in the 1990s.
It is assumed that you cannot receive this case until you have saved Evil Dave in the Recipe for Disaster quest.
When Oziach is called to the stand for questioning, he still has the "Trade" chat option when right clicked, although it is impossible to reach him to do so.