A Box of Valentine chocolates could be obtained by purchasing a chocolate with 50 Valentine love notes. Along with the box, you also received a random chocolate which could be added to the box. After adding two chocolates of each type, you received [Name] the Scrumptious and [Name] the Forlorn titles, along with five small XP lamps that gave experience to your five lowest skills (determined by experience). After adding a chocolate in the box, you could not take them out.
Once completed, it could not be done again; attempting to do so gave the message: "You have already completed this Valentine's challenge."